Yoast vs Rank Math: WordPress SEO Plugins Compared

Dominik Stein Last updated 17.11.2020
13 Min.
WordPress  SEO plugins
Last updated 17.11.2020

The number of good WordPress SEO Plugins is manageable. When researching search engine optimization (SEO) tools, one almost always comes across Yoast SEO - currently the most popular solution when it comes to SEO optimization of WordPress . But recently, there is a new competitor that has been able to build a huge community within a very short period of time: Rank Math.

Which plugin is the better solution for the search engine optimization of your website? What are the strengths and weaknesses of each tool? Our WordPress comparison of Rank Math vs. Yoast SEO.

What does an SEO plugin do?

Before we get to the showdown between the two plugins, I'd like to dispel a myth I hear all too often from new customers:

A SEO plugin helps you optimize your website. But neither Yoast SEO nor Rank Math can be the perfect "jack of all trades".

There is so much more to search engine optimization. Starting with the speed of your website, keyword research or your content. You want to learn which measures have an actual effect on your website? Then check out my tutorial "How to perform an SEO audit ".

Remember: a plugin alone is never enough

The installation of a SEO plugin alone is not enough! Even if some extensions and experience reports on the market want to give you that feeling. Changing to another plugin will almost NEVER magically double your traffic.

The typical tasks of an SEO plugin include:

  • Giving the search engines instructions on which content/URLs may be crawled
  • Providing instructions in the robots.txt
  • Generating a sitemap
  • Analysis of your posts and pages including SEO recommendations for action
  • Management of your redirects
  • Providing structured data

But no single solution works straight out of the box. What you do with the recommendations, how you write your content and how you configure the plugin - all these responsibilites lie with you.

Yoast SEO

Yoast SEO is the most widely used SEO Plugin and is currently used on over 5 million active WordPress websites. In addition, Yoast SEO is committed to the further development of WordPress and regularly participates as a speaker at WordPress conferences.

Yoast SEO WordPress
The Yoast SEO plugin on WordPress.org

Yoast SEO has been on the market since 2010 and is based in the Netherlands. According to its own information, more than 80 employees are currently working on the Plugin.

Functions of Yoast SEO

Yoast SEO is available in a free and a premium version. Overall, this plugin works perfectly in the free version. As a premium user, you can activate a few additional functions and reduce the need for additional plugins. Here's an overview of the two versions:

Free SEO Plugin
Yoast SEO premium compared with Yoast SEO free

Setup (setup manager)

Yoast SEO comes with a setup manager. This tool is designed to help newcomers make the right choices in the settings. The manager may look solid at first glance but it has several weaknesses. Many options are simply left out of this manager despite being extrememly important settings, e.g. the indexing of categories and keywords.

Yoast Wizard
The Wizard or Setup Manager of Yoast

What should happen with taxonomies, you can decide afterwards only in the advanced settings. I find this critical, because many WordPress users use keywords and categories incorrectly - and therefore create unnecessary or duplicate urls or even duplicate content.

Yoast Tags
The settings for categories and tags

In 90 percent of all optimizations for new customers, I first have to clean up the taxonomies because they were previously used incorrectly. The Setup Wizard has not convinced me here.

Keyword optimization

The biggest and most useful feature are the recommendations for keyword optimization. Especially for beginners, these recommendations give quite a few hints on what you should pay attention to when optimizing your content for search engines.

Keyword research guide

The research of suitable keywords is an important SEO lever. I'll guide you step by step through the entire process: Tutorial on keyword research. Including recommendations, examples and tools.

And here we also come to one of the biggest weaknesses of Yoast SEO. It suggests good rankings by bringing the recommendations into the green area. Especially when optimizing the focus keyword, it can quickly come to an over-optimization, because the tool does not recognize synonyms accurately.

Readability Content SEO
Hints for the readability of your posts

Overall, Yoast's recommendations for action are good. However, some of these tips will have very little effect on your rankings. By this I mean: The recommendation is still important, but maybe you could invest the time better in other weaknesses of the website. New users tend to over-optimize here as well.

In addition to the recommendations for action, you can customize the meta description and meta title of your sites. They form that important text preview that will later be visible in the search results of Google

SERP snippet
Preview of the snippet in the SERPs

In addition to the keyword optimization, users get access to the readability index. The Flesch calculation determines how "easy" your text is to read. Based on the analysis, Yoast creates recommendations on how you can simplify your text.

Yoast Analysis
The detailed results of the analysis

Personally, I don't use the tool at all, because I always have the impression that the tool pushes me to keyword stuffing or to make big changes to my texts. Therefore, I only occasionally take a look at the analysis - and follow the recommendations if I think they make sense. Again, green lights will not necessarily lead to better rankings.

Structured data

Structured data is used to provide search engines with additional information about your website or content. The importance of structured data for search engine optimization has been growing steadily in recent years. See my SEO Guide for 2020 for an explanation.

In most cases, you can use Schema Code to enable additional display options in the search results. For example, the display of review stars:

Stars preview scheme
Star ratings increase Google's attention

If you have made all the settings, then the Plugin generates structured data from your information (for example, from your company name), which can later be read by search engines. This can be information about the website, such as the company or your blog. Or which social channels belong to your website. Evaluated by the Structured Data Tester, it looks something like this:

Structured Data Test
A Structured Data Test

In addition, the Gutenberg editor allows you to easily add two more schema types - the How-To and FAQ boxes. You can create these directly in the editor of Gutenberg :

Gutenberg FAQ Box
Create a FAQ box in Gutenberg

Here is an example of how such a FAQ box is displayed in Google's search results:

FAQ Box in the SERPs
The FAQ in the SERPs

To be fair though, there are countless other schema variations (for example rich cards, reviews, events) that are not supported by Yoast SEO.

Regular updates

With the slogan "Always updated for Google's algorithm" Yoast SEO advertises to always be optimized for the latest algorithm. This is nonsense, of course, because Yoast has as little insight into this as any other person in the public.

However, the Plugin is updated every 14 days. This promises that the Plugin works as flawlessly as possible with current versions of WordPress . And that possible security holes are also removed at regular intervals.

Redirect Manager (Premium)

One reason to switch to the premium version is Yoast's Redirect Manager. The interface is very user-friendly and easy to use.

Yoast Redirect
Create redirect with Yoast

In addition, when deleting or editing posts, users are asked whether they want to set a 301 redirect. Especially in large teams or with inexperienced colleagues, these security questions can prevent serious traffic losses.

Trash WordPress
Warnings when deleting posts in WordPress

Advantages and disadvantages of Yoast SEO

The biggest advantage of Yoast SEO is its compatibility with other WordPress Themes and Plugins. This is because the Plugin is one of the most widely used SEO Plugins . And after 10 years of its release, it can also be confidently said that the Plugin does its job on the majority of the websites without any problem.

Updates are made regularly and the Yoast team also responds to support requests promptly. However, premium users have absolute priority here. This means that you may have to wait a little longer as a user of the free version - or that the answer only refers to previous tutorials. This is a reason to think about buying the premium version.

Many developers often criticize that the code and the Plugin is overloaded with too many functions. This can lead to complications, vulnerabilities in the security of your website or slow loading times. Partly I have to agree with this. For example, some features that are included in Plugin are simply useless. For example, the integration of Ryte in Yoast SEO offers no added value and could be removed in my opinion:

Ryte Yoast
Ryte Integration from Yoast SEO

In addition, there have been complications in the updates in the past that have led to indexing problems or security vulnerabilities.

Rank Math

Rank Math comes from the makers of "MyThemeShop". RankMath is according to WordPress .org RankMath is currently used on over 200,000 active WordPress websites. There is hardly any information about the company itself. Also not to the persons, who support the project substantially. Background might be that the company has its origin in India.

Rank Math WordPress  SEO Plugin
Rank Math at WordPress.org

I first came into contact with Rank Math in July 2017 - when MyThemeShop asked me if I wanted to participate in the closed beta testing. Then, in November 2019, the official release happened. And thus only two months after the feedback of the closed beta. I felt this timing was too early.

Functions of Rank Math

The Plugin is free in all its previous functions. The developers have already admitted several times that the Plugin will later receive a premium variant. Existing functions are nevertheless to remain free of charge. Experience has shown that there is always a risk that such statements will not be kept.

However, I am curious which functions the developers still want to integrate into the Plugin . Because the majority of all SEO-relevant settings are already included in Plugin . At the moment, the Rank Math team is probably considering using automations to create further incentives for a premium version.

Rank Math Functions
The functions of Rank Math according to the provider

Setup (setup manager)

Already in the setup manager you can see that the Plugin is strongly oriented towards Yoast SEO. Nevertheless, the setup process is more detailed and better described. Even advanced settings like taxonomies, NoFollow, sitemaps etc. are included. For example, you can automatically assign the "NoIndex" tag to categories that do not yet contain URLs:

NoIndex Rank Math
Link and index optimizations in Rank Math

Automatic updates can also be activated in the Setup Manager for this Plugin , but as a rule you should always check new versions on your own test system:

Automatic Plugin updates
Optional: Automatic updates of the SEO plugins

What is striking is the possibility to take over all previous settings from the Yoast SEO Plugin . A function that worked amazingly well in the test! Even the status codes of previous redirects were transferred without any problems. However, this import only works in one direction. A return from Rank Math to Yoast SEO is not possible automatically. You should keep that in mind during the installation.

Import Rank Math Yoast
The Rank Math Yoast Importer

I find it critical that the Setup Manager requires registration. According to support, this can be skipped via "Cancel", but this is not clear. In addition, it is not explained why a registration should be necessary. Only via the forum of WordPress one receives corresponding information:

WordPress  Support
Statement in the support forum on WordPress.org

I would like to see more transparency here.

Test Rank Math

At https://demo.rankmat h.com you can test the interface of WordPress Plugins - without having to install it on your own site . For example to compare it with Yoast SEO.

Keyword analysis

The keyword analysis is also strongly oriented towards Yoast SEO. You can find it in the sidebar of the Gutenberg editor. On the positive side: You can add as many synonyms as you like. Nevertheless, the analysis by Yoast SEO is more detailed. For example, Rank Math does not take ALT tags into account, the readability index (Flesch Test) does not currently include european language. In addition, Yoast has hired its own linguist for this feature, so Yoast has a significant head start here.

Yoast vs Rank Math: WordPress SEO Plugins Compared
The keyword analysis in Rank Math for WordPress

In addition to keyword analysis, Rank Math has another tool that I find very interesting as a search engine optimizer. An integrated, general SEO analysis:

SEO analysis
Overview: Rank Math's SEO Analysis

This tool is well suited for beginners. The analysis takes only a few seconds and returns a superficial evaluation of the website. For example, you will be informed whether your website is crawlable, whether meta descriptions are available or how the website performs in a SpeedTest.

Speed Test Rank Math
The SpeedTest from Rank Math

For beginners this test may be very good. Whereby I must criticize that many of the suggestions (auto updates, visibility of Plugins) are not SEO-relevant. In addition, the test does not say much about which sites of the domain are optimized below average. Therefore, the add-on is only worthwhile for the one-time use - you can then deactivate it again.

Structured data

Those who know MyThemeShop know that the company has years of experience in the integration of schema data. RankMath has made use of this experience from its own Themes . So you can choose in the Gutenberg editor which structured data should be used for the post. This makes it easy to generate rich cards from a post, for example for events, people or recipes:

Rank Math Scheme
Scheme variants of Rank Math in Gutenberg

Yoast, on the other hand, only supports structured data for FAQ & How-To boxes. These are now even included in Rank Math. So Rank Math wins this comparison. Additionally, the settings in the backend generate structured data for companies, people or organizations. Just like Yoast.

Performance

The biggest advantage that speaks for Rank Math: The plugin's code is supposedly much less overloaded than the Yoast code. This is achieved on the one hand by the fact that the plugin is modular. Additional options can be easily deactivated in the backend and are then no longer used by the plugin's backend. This way you can tailor your SEO plugin to the way you need it.

According to Rank Math, it consists of about 30,000 lines of code, whereas other tools manage an average of 50,000 lines of code. Lean source code brings advantages. Not only does less code and thus fewer queries have a better impact on the performance of your site , they also allow fewer entry points for hackers. On the other hand, there are hardly any independent test values on the web that compare the actual impact on load time.

Extensions

When it comes to the feature set of both Plugins , Rank Math is the clear winner in this comparison. In the add-on section, you can activate or deactivate the following additional functions as desired:

  • 404 Monitor
  • Advanced Custom Fields & AMP
  • bbPress, buddyPress
  • Link Counter, Local SEO & Google Knowledge Graph
  • Redirects, Schema Structured Data
  • Role Manager, Search Console, SEO Analysis, Sitemap
  • WooCommerce
Rank Math Add-Ons
Part of the Rank Math extensions

Many of these features are not included in Yoast SEO or can only be unlocked via paid extensions. Yonas Tietgen has reported about many of the features in his blog.

Advantages and disadvantages of Rank Math

Although this plugin is free, the support seems to be very good. It responds to requests within 24 hours. There is both a forum and a Facebook group where support requests or questions can be asked. The scope of services outshines any other free SEO plugin. And the interface is both easy to understand and very sophisticated.

Disadvantages include a lack of transparency about the developers or vendors behind Plugin , as well as reports of fake reviews being created on WordPress .org. When joining the Facebook group or using Google search, there are almost exclusively positive reports. And even in my one-year membership in the beta community, I often had the impression that the Plugin was praised too much to the skies by other users.

Or that prospective customers are urged to absolutely perform a migration from Yoast SEO to Rank Math. Such a migration of the settings is possible, but not from Rank Math to Yoast. I don't want to badmouth the Plugin or the community, but it doesn't seem quite clean to me.

Rank Math vs Yoast SEO - Who Wins?

For me, Yoast SEO is the winner. Rank Math is cool, without question. And it's also ahead in terms of interface, feature set, and the idea behind it. But one look at the support forum is enough and you quickly realize that Plugin is still in its infancy.

Here Yoast SEO has the longer experience and the larger team clearly ahead. Yoast SEO is compatible with several WordPress Plugins and Themes . And with the huge spread, many other programmers have also adapted their Plugins and Themes to Yoast SEO. For example, in some Themes/frameworks, Yoast SEO breadcrumbs can be used instead of Theme breadcrumbs. And all this without interfering with the code. By the way, this is also the reason why I haven't switched to Rank Math yet.

Therefore, I stick to my conclusion: Rank Math is better than Yoast SEO in terms of functionality. But for WordPress beginners, I would rather go for Yoast SEO just because of the greater compatibility - and save myself potential problems. Still, Rank Math is an interesting approach to keep watching.

Should you switch from Yoast SEO to RankMath?

I'd advise against it. Unless you know 100% of what you're doing. A new SEO plugin doesn't automatically mean better rankings. Neither yoast SEO nor RankMath can assure you of that. There is a much higher chance that problems will occur during the change and that the changes will have a negative effect on your traffic.

Rather invest your time in topics that really have to do with search engine optimization: An SEO audit, the content of your website and the user experience. Then you'll benefit from higher conversions or faster loading times. See my SEO Guide 2020 for more tips.

Do I need Yoast SEO Premium as a RAIDBOXES customer?

If features like "internal link recommendations", "content insights" or "ad-free" are important to you - then yes. However, the most important selling point for Yoast SEO is the Redirect Manager. However, you can also create temporary or permanent manual redirects in your BOXES from RAIDBOXES , including rules (Rewrite Rules):

301 and 302 Forwarding
Setting up 301 and 302 redirects at RAIDBOXES

Then you can also use Yoast SEO in the free version without any problems - and are therefore not dependent on this feature.

For whom is Rank Math suitable?

For any new installation or website with WordPress , that has not used an SEO tool before. Since the Plugin is still in its infancy: I recommend the Plugin more for people who have time to deal with support in case of emergency. Or who have programming skills to solve any problems themselves.

Rank Math is a very interesting tool in terms of functions Plugin. But to switch from another SEO Plugin solely because of this can also have a negative effect.

Your questions about WordPress SEO Plugins

What questions do you have about Rank Math or Yoast SEO? Which tools can you recommend? Feel free to use the comment function. Want more tips on WordPress and performance? Then follow us on Twitter, Facebook or via our newsletter.

What started as a passion has become Dominik's profession. Today, as a search engine optimizer, he advises companies across Europe in the implementation of onpage and offpage measures. Or implements them himself. As an up-and-coming blogger, Dominik shares his knowledge about search engine optimization in his SEO blog.

Related articles

Comments on this article

An
Anup Dubey

Hi, Thanks for the detailed review. Based on the analysis I think Rank Math outweighs Yoast. I have used RankMath but switched back to Yoast free due to some indexing issues. I am not sure whether the issues were due to RankMath or any other reason. Now After reading this article I am again thinking to switch back to RankMath due to more features and good UI.

An
Akash Golder

sir, what's a explanation, and to be honest I'm loosing my traffic using rank math, I think yoast is far better then rank math, and now I'm moving rank math to yoast seoeo plugin...! again sir thank you very very much ♥♥

An
Ahmad Al Hariri

I am using the Rank math Plugin Four days ago, I had posts which were for google unique Today I found those posts are not more in the First page as they were.
Also I am using a self built WordPress theme . With YOAST SEO Was great, but with Rank math Plugin is full with Critical Errors.. It is not easy to decide which Is better yes but as you said who Wins , SEO YOST as well as The Support team there is better and faster....

D
Deepika singh

Yoast and Rank Math seo are the two most popular plugins right now. Some suggest Yoast is best and some say Rank math is the best.
In my view if someone has the yoast premium plan then they don't need any other plugin. But if someone is looking for a free seo plugin then Rank math is worth it.

Post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *.